The National Research Center for Career and Technical Education released a new report today regarding programs of study, identifying factors supporting the successful development of POS, drawing from three studies being conducted in the field. Below is the summary of the study, as published in NRCCTE’s Center Point newsletter.
Programs of Study: A Cross-Study Examination of Programs in Three States
This project was designed to examine selected programs and sites from each of the Center’s three field-based, longitudinal studies of POS that had the most mature, well-established programs relative to other study sites as a means of identifying common elements or attributes that led to the successful implementation of POS. A team of researchers led by Rob Shumer of the University of Minnesota, Sam Stringfield and Natalie Stipanovic of the University of Louisville, and Nora Murphy of the University of Minnesota conducted visits to three sites over the course of the 2010-2011 school year. During these visits, the study team reviewed each site’s strengths, identified the contributing factors to their development of POS, and examined their implementation of the 10 supporting elements of POS identified by the U.S. Department of Education, Office of Vocational and Adult Education. After describing the sites, the report identifies six major themes derived from the data gathered at these sites:
- Engagement: POS had the power to engage students in learning, primarily by connecting academic learning to meaningful, work-based learning.
- Strong focus on student learning: POS were established to ensure that learning, both academic and skills-based, was the primary activity of students.
- Certification of knowledge and skills: As mandated, POS led to a variety of certifications from business and industry. But academic knowledge also had to meet levels of certification or generate outcomes that could be measured against standards.
- POS connected secondary and postsecondary systems with the goal of making CTE a seamless system that starts early in students’ educational careers and focuses on both academic and skills-based learning.
- POS raised the understanding of and respect for CTE among stakeholders.
- High-quality teachers made a difference in the delivery of programs.
This study of three sites selected from the NRCCTE’s field-based longitudinal research projects offers important knowledge about how POS work and what needs to be done to continue positive trends in program outcomes and operations. It has also captured many of the strengths of the programs that contribute to engagement, learning, collaboration, and cooperation. As the renewal of the Carl D. Perkins legislation approaches, the findings from this study may help inform future efforts in the expansion of POS and the creation of an integrated, seamless system of learning that will engage students in training for work, college, and life.
To learn more about the team’s findings and recommendations for the future of programs of study, download the full report:
Shumer, R., Stringfield, S., Stipanovic, N., & Murphy, N. (2011, November). Programs of study: A cross-study examination of programs in three states. Louisville, KY: National Research Center for Career and Technical Education, University of Louisville. (PDF document)
Companion Podcast:
Related to the report, authors Sam Stringfield and Rob Shumer recently joined Catherine Imperatore of ACTE to talk about the study’s design, process, and outcomes. Their conversation, recorded as a podcast, dwelt particularly on the six major themes that emerged from the team’s rich pool of transcript data, as well as the study team’s recommendations regarding the future of POS.
Programs of Study: A Cross-Study Examination of Programs in Three States – A Podcast with Sam Stringfield and Robert Shumer.
To subscribe to this newsletter, contact the editor. Contact info available at http://www.nrccte.org/.